Before You Start
This guide is for finance managers, bookkeepers, and business owners currently evaluating expense management solutions. We assume you’re familiar with basic accounting concepts.
Overview
What You’ll Learn
- Key differences in pricing models
- How each tool handles receipt capture and data extraction
- User experience and reporting capabilities
- Compatibility with popular accounting software
- Strengths and weaknesses for various business needs
1. Preparation Steps
Before diving into a comparison, consider these factors for your business:
Core Considerations
- Number of employees/users needing expense management
- Volume of expenses and receipts processed monthly
- Integration with existing accounting software (QuickBooks Online, Xero, etc.)
- Requirement for corporate credit card reconciliation
Advanced Features to Ponder
- Automated policy enforcement and approval workflows
- Advanced reporting and analytics needs
- Multi-currency and international expense support
- Specific needs like mileage tracking or per diems
2. Expensify vs. Dext: At a Glance
You have two main options, each with serious pros and cons.
Expensify: Focus on Employee Reimbursement
This tool excels at employee-centric expense reporting.
- Highly user-friendly for employees.
- Robust mobile app for receipt capture.
- Automated expense policy enforcement.
- Direct corporate card integration.
- Can be complex for basic bookkeeping.
- ”Collect” pricing can be costly for low volume.
- Limited customization for advanced GL codes.
Dext: Focus on Data Extraction & Bookkeeping
This tool prioritizes accurate data capture for accountants.
Expert Tip: Choosing between Expensify and Dext largely depends on whether your primary need is robust employee reimbursement and policy enforcement (Expensify) or highly efficient receipt data capture and bookkeeping integration (Dext).
3. Key Feature Comparison
Here’s a detailed look at how each platform handles common expense management tasks.
Here is a sample data structure for an expense, illustrating typical fields.
{
"expense_id": "EXPNFY-12345",
"date": "2025-10-20",
"merchant": "Starbucks",
"amount": 5.50,
"currency": "USD",
"category": "Meals & Entertainment",
"status": "Submitted"
}4. Pricing and Integration
- 1
Expensify Setup & Pricing
Expensify primarily uses a “Collect” pricing model based on monthly active users. Setup involves connecting bank/card feeds, defining expense policies, and linking to your accounting software (QBO, Xero, etc.) for automated journal entries.
- 2
Dext Setup & Pricing
Dext typically offers tiered pricing based on document volume. Setup involves connecting various receipt sources (email, cloud storage, mobile app), setting up suppliers and categories for AI training, and integrating directly with accounting platforms for automated publishing.
- 3
Integration Best Practices
For both, ensure your chart of accounts in your accounting software is well-organized before integration. Map categories and vendors carefully to prevent mispostings and ease reconciliation.
Common Error: Neglecting Policy Setup
Failing to properly configure expense policies in Expensify can lead to compliance issues and manual review. For Dext, insufficient categorization setup can result in more manual tagging and slower processing.
5. Choosing the Right Tool
Decision Checklist
- Does the pricing model align with your budget and usage?
- How important is employee ease-of-use vs. bookkeeping efficiency?
- What is your primary need: robust employee reimbursement or precise data capture?
- Does it integrate smoothly with your current accounting system (e.g., QuickBooks, Xero)?
- Are advanced features like automated policy enforcement or mileage tracking critical for your operations?
Need Help?
Get Expert Guidance
Still unsure which expense solution is right for your business? Our team can help you evaluate and implement the perfect fit.
Contact Us